Cliomuse.com
Where history and movies meet
Cliomuse.com
  • Featured Movies
    • 12 Years a Slave (2013)
    • 1941 (Spielberg) >
      • 1941: Part 2
    • Affair of the Necklace
    • Alice's Restaurant: best of the American counterculture movies?
    • Army of Crime
    • Army of Shadows
    • The Artist >
      • 'The Artist':2
    • Anthropoid: the Assassination of Reinhard Heydrich, 1942: Four Very Different Movies >
      • Hangmen Also Die: Hollywood meets emigres from Nazi Germany
    • Autobiography of Miss Jane Pittman
    • Battle of the Rails ( La bataille du rail)
    • Belle (2014)
    • Bhowani Junction
    • Blackboard Jungle >
      • Blackboard Jungle Pt.2
    • Carry On Up the Khyber
    • Charlie Wilson's War
    • The City Across the River
    • The Counterculture : best movies about the American counterculture era
    • Custer - two contrasting movie portrayals: "They Died With Their Boots On" and "Little Big Man" >
      • They Died With Their Boots On
      • Stalin and the Movies >
        • Stalin, Disney, Eisenstein, & Ivan the Terrible
      • Death of Stalin
      • Little Big Man (1970)
    • Dark Knight Rises >
      • Dark Knight Rises Pt.2
    • The Deceivers
    • Diplomacy / Diplomatie (2014) movie
    • Dunkirk: Christopher Nolan's epic movie
    • El Cid
    • The Enigma Machine : four movies about the Enigma machine
    • Generation War >
      • Generation War: Jazz and the Swing Kids
      • Generation War: German women and the war
    • The Great Gatsby On the Big Screen
    • Gunga Din
    • A Hard Day's Night: Influences on the Movie
    • Hemingway & Gellhorn >
      • Martha Gellhorn >
        • Women war correspondents
    • Hyde Park on Hudson
    • The Imitation Game (2014) >
      • The Imitation Game Part 2: the truth about Turing and the Bletchley 'Bombe'. >
        • The Imitation Game: Turing, Bletchley and the Colossus >
          • Imitation Game: Turing, Bletchley Park and the Soviet spy
    • The Inner Circle (1991)
    • Is Paris Burning? >
      • Is Paris Burning? General von Choltitz
    • KIng of the Khyber Rifles
    • Kim
    • Léon Morin, Priest
    • Les Miserables (2012) >
      • Les Miserables in Movies: Fantine the grisette >
        • Les Miserables 3: guide to some historical references
    • "Les Misérables": Claude Lelouch updates a classic
    • Lives of a Bengal Lancer (1935)
    • The Long Duel
    • Looking at Lincoln - Spielberg's "Lincoln" & its predecessors and influences >
      • Spielberg's Lincoln
      • Abraham Lincoln: D.W. Griffith's version
      • Young Mr. Lincoln (1939)
      • Abe Lincoln in Illinois
    • Mandingo (1975) Dir: Richard Fleischer
    • The Man Who Would Be King
    • Marie Antoinette (2006)
    • Marie-Antoinette / Shadow of the Guillotine
    • Farewell, My Queen
    • Marie Antoinette (1938) >
      • Marie Antoinette (1938) Pt.2
    • Mayerling
    • Midnight in Paris >
      • Midnight in Paris:2 >
        • Midnight in Paris:3
    • The Monuments Men (2014) Dir: George Clooney
    • North West Frontier / Flame Over India
    • La Nuit de Varennes - a post-modern take on a key episode in the French Revolution
    • Le Pere Tranquille (The Quiet Father) 1946
    • Peterloo: MIke Leigh's New Movie >
      • Peterloo2
    • Pompeii in the movies >
      • Pompeii (2014) Paul W.S. Anderson director
    • Rebel Without a Cause
    • Ridicule
    • Scott Fitzgerald Goes to Hollywood
    • Sergeant Rutledge
    • Silence of the Sea
    • Swing Kids (1993)
    • The Train
    • Train to Pakistan
    • Stranglers of Bombay
    • Tonka
    • Tulip Fever
    • Viceroy's House
    • The Vikings
    • Vietnam Westerns: western movies and the Vietnam war
    • Wee Willie Winkie
    • The Wind and the Lion
    • Woman in Gold >
      • Woman in Gold Pt.2: the Vienna Scene in early 20th Century Vienna
    • Un village française: French TV series
    • Waterloo: the movie about Napoleon's final battle
    • Zabriskie Point
  • Places
    • Settings: the North West Frontier
    • Movies Set in the North-West Frontier >
      • Thuggees
    • Movies Set in Paris and Versailles
  • Events
    • Events That Inspired Movies 2
    • French Resistance and Collaboration in World War II: Selected Movies
  • People
    • People Part 2
  • Music
    • Rock Around the Clock
    • Don't Knock the Rock
    • The Girl Can't Help It >
      • Pt2:The Girl Can't Help It
  • Free State of Jones
  • Great Wall (2017)
  • Rogue One & World War 2
  • Hollywood and anti-Americanism in a small country: Amercan movies & their critics in New Zealand 1916 - 1956
    • New Zealanders' Love of Movies 1900s-1956
    • Campaign against Hollywood movies in New Zealand
    • Campaign against HollywoodPt 2
  • Hollywood versus Pinewood Pt2
  • New Zealanders and Movies: the Enigmatic Gordon Mirams: film critic, film censor and public intellectual
  • Aryan Papers: Stanley Kubrick's Proposed Movie

The Imitation Game: Turing, Bletchley and the Colossus Machine

Picture
Picture
Two views of a  Colossus machine at Bletchley Park. Eventually ten or twelve 'Colossi' were built . Left image shows a couple of the WREN officers who tended the machines. Howard Campaigne, one of the experts working on Colossus describes the Wrens as "very skilled and adroit.... Without the Wrens 1 was helpless."
Colossus obviously was a completely different beast from the Bombe that features in The Imitation Game. The movie occasionally confuses the two different functions and tasks of the two technologies. Unfortunately, it also inaccurately continues the now discredited claims that Turing and his Bletchley team designed and built the machine that in 1944 cracked  the particularly difficult German military encryptions used by Hitler and his high command. This machine was called Colossus. Turing statistical analysis theories  offered insights but the essential breakthrough was carried out by  Max Newman who, on reaching an impasse, handed the task over to a team of brilliant Post Officers electro-engineers led by Thomas Flowers and working in suburban London. In a few months Flowers and his team designed and built Colossus, and handed it over to Bletchley where it was put into immediate use.
The side view of a Colossus [below,left) indicates the size and complexity of the machine. A recently reconstructed, working Colossus is shown below, right.
Picture
Picture
What was the purpose of Colossus? And what was Turing's role?
The Colossus machine should not be confused with the Bombe. It was much more sophisticated, powerful and expensive, and worked on cracking a different and much more difficult and important German  code.(nicknamed Tunny by the British). As one authority tersely  concludes: 
Alan Turing did not become the chief figure in the Tunny work, and in particular did not design or build the Colossus, as is often incorrectly stated. Colossus was not applied to Enigma ciphers! However, it depended on the statistical theory that Alan Turing had developed for breaking the naval Enigma. 
[www.turing.org.uk/scrapbook/electronic.htm]
By  1943 the Germans were using their Enigma machines mainly for field work. But for high-level communications, including messages from Hitler and military headquarters including  communication  of military strategy and troop  movements, the Germans were using a much more sophisticated encoding  device.  This used  a different type of machine from Enigma: the teleprinter-based Lorenz SZ 40 and SZ 42 machines, designed by the AG Company. This was a bigger, heavier machine using fixed circuits and teleprinter mechanisms. It';s code-cracking capabilities were an incredible 5,429,503,678,976 times greater than the Enigma system. Bletchley Park had the advantage of using actual Enigma machines to help crack the Enigma code, but only after the D-Day landings did a couple of  the SZ machines make their way to England. But by then the Tunny code had already been broken.

Picture
A Lorenz SZ 40 -42 - electro-mechanical wheel-based enciphering machine for teleprinter signalling.
Picture
Close-up of a Lorenz Machine. Bletchley Park was surprised by how relatively compact they were.
Picture
Max Newman.
The credit for this feat, which enabled Bletchley  to learn of the whereabouts and movements of German military formations, often attributed solely to Turing (not that he claimed it) was shared by several people and by institiutions other than Bletchley. Turing supplied  crucial statistical analysis. But the real breakthrough came through the efforts of a brilliant Cambridge mathematician, Max Newman, whose German father had been interned during World War I. Newman was called upon to work at Bletchley  in 1942. He insisted that the Tunny code could be broken mechanically by automated processes and began designing  a machine for that task.  His initial construction, built at a Bletchley hut called 'the  Newmanr  - was  nicknamed Heath Robinson after an illustrator who drew amusing, fantastical machines - though flawed, proved that mechanisation and automation  was indeed the fastest, simplest way to go. But by 1943 Newman realised that the machine he devised was too slow and inefficient to be effective. So he turned to anothe, much less glamorous institution and to a modest  engineering genius.


Picture
From the official Gneral Report on Tunny, p. 38. Publication forbidden for several decades after the end of the war,
That man was Thomas (Tommy)  Flowers, and the institution was an essential but overlooked structure iin Britain's twentieth century communications network: the GPO [Government Post Office] Research Station located in the mundane suburban setting of  Dollis Hill in Northwest London.
Flowers, born in  London's working-class East End in 1905, son of a bricklayer, gained an elecctrical engineering degree whiole working as an apprentice mecanical engineer and went to work for the British  GPO at the age of twenty-one. At that time the GPO ran the nation's telecommunication network. he soon moved to Dollis Hill, using electronics to make a faster, more reliable long-distance telephone system. Although he is sometimes credited with creating the world's first computer  (Colossus) he admittedly that  "1 was not myself interested so much in computers as in telephone exchanges."
 By the start of the war Flowers was recognised as a brilliant electronics and telecommunications expert. He was a pioneer in using electronic valves in repeater stations  to simplify  and accelerate the whole system of making automatic phone calls over long distances. Years after the end of the war Flowers wrote that "The real origin of the Colossus machines was the work I did before the war at the Dollis Hill Research Station of the Post Office."
When assigned to design Colossus in 1943, Flowers insisted that an all-electronic process was necessary, using electronic valves to accelerate the deciphering process - an idea received skeptically by Bletchley, especially by one of its  chiefs, Gordon Welchman, who, according to Max Hastings“treated him with disdain, as a mere artisan with ideas above his station”.
 But accorig to Flowers  "[such] riticism could be defeated by the experience of the Post Office using thousands of tubes in its communication network." 
Flowers' Dollis Hill team produced the first Colossus within 11 months - " a feat made possible," he drily observed, "by the absolute priority they were given to command materials and services and the prodigious efforts of the laboratory staff, many of whom did nothing but work, eat, and sleep for weeks and months on end except for one half day per week that they allowed themselves for the necessities of life such as talking to their wives and getting their hair cut."
By D-Day Dollis Hill had delivered two of the Colossus machines to Bletchley Hill. They enabled the Allies to decipher vital German intelligence revealing that  Hitler and the German High Command believed the forthcoming invasion would  occur at Pas de Calais, not Normandy.  They also revelaed the location and size of key German units in France and Belgium and their likely movements. The successful D-Day landings also gave Coloussus and Bletchley an enormous bonus. Allied air forces and French resistance targeted German telephine and teleprinter communications in France, forcing the Germans to rely on radio transmission of their Lorenz codes. This made interception and decipherment of the such messages easier and faster.
After D Day the French resistance and the British and American Air Forces bombed and strafed all the telephone and teleprinter land lines in Northern France, forced the Germans to use radio communications and suddenly the volume of intercepted messages went up enormously.
After the end of the war Flowers received a British Honours award of an MBE plus a thousand pounds sterling in partial compensation for spending his own money in making equipment for Colossus. His crucial role in designing and engineering Colossus remained unknown until the 1970s and then it remained overshadowed by the emerging publicity given to Turing and his team at Bletchley. Even today Flowers' amazing contribution iswidely ignored.As Max Hastings writes in his recent  monumental history of espionage and coding during the conflict, The Secret War, Flowers reeceived 
"a shamefully condescending  recognition of his role as begetter of Colossus. Most Bletchley hands attest thathe was the practical brain who played a pivotal role in t ranslating the concepts of Turing , Newman and Wynn-Williams into reality. and indeed for advancing them to a new level of sophistication."
Quotes from "The Design of Colossus" by Thomas Flowers, article in "Boole and computer logic",  Annals of the History of Computing, Volume 5, Number 3, July 1983 . p239; Max Hastings, The secret War Spies, Codes and Guerillas 1939-1945  (London, 2015), Ch.15 esp pp.415-416
Picture
GPO Research Station, Dollis Hill.
Picture
Thomas Flowers, the self-effacing engineer who designed Colossus.
Picture
Page from Flower's diary: January 16, 1944 - 'made Colossus work'. Two days later he noted: 'Colossus moved to BP' [Bletchley Park]