Cliomuse.com
Where history and movies meet
Cliomuse.com
  • Featured Movies
    • 12 Years a Slave (2013)
    • 1941 (Spielberg) >
      • 1941: Part 2
    • Affair of the Necklace
    • Alice's Restaurant: best of the American counterculture movies?
    • Army of Crime
    • Army of Shadows
    • The Artist >
      • 'The Artist':2
    • Anthropoid: the Assassination of Reinhard Heydrich, 1942: Four Very Different Movies >
      • Hangmen Also Die: Hollywood meets emigres from Nazi Germany
    • Autobiography of Miss Jane Pittman
    • Battle of the Rails ( La bataille du rail)
    • Belle (2014)
    • Bhowani Junction
    • Blackboard Jungle >
      • Blackboard Jungle Pt.2
    • Carry On Up the Khyber
    • Charlie Wilson's War
    • The City Across the River
    • The Counterculture : best movies about the American counterculture era
    • Custer - two contrasting movie portrayals: "They Died With Their Boots On" and "Little Big Man" >
      • They Died With Their Boots On
      • Stalin and the Movies >
        • Stalin, Disney, Eisenstein, & Ivan the Terrible
      • Death of Stalin
      • Little Big Man (1970)
    • Dark Knight Rises >
      • Dark Knight Rises Pt.2
    • The Deceivers
    • Diplomacy / Diplomatie (2014) movie
    • Dunkirk: Christopher Nolan's epic movie
    • El Cid
    • The Enigma Machine : four movies about the Enigma machine
    • Generation War >
      • Generation War: Jazz and the Swing Kids
      • Generation War: German women and the war
    • The Great Gatsby On the Big Screen
    • Gunga Din
    • A Hard Day's Night: Influences on the Movie
    • Hemingway & Gellhorn >
      • Martha Gellhorn >
        • Women war correspondents
    • Hyde Park on Hudson
    • The Imitation Game (2014) >
      • The Imitation Game Part 2: the truth about Turing and the Bletchley 'Bombe'. >
        • The Imitation Game: Turing, Bletchley and the Colossus >
          • Imitation Game: Turing, Bletchley Park and the Soviet spy
    • The Inner Circle (1991)
    • Is Paris Burning? >
      • Is Paris Burning? General von Choltitz
    • KIng of the Khyber Rifles
    • Kim
    • Léon Morin, Priest
    • Les Miserables (2012) >
      • Les Miserables in Movies: Fantine the grisette >
        • Les Miserables 3: guide to some historical references
    • "Les Misérables": Claude Lelouch updates a classic
    • Lives of a Bengal Lancer (1935)
    • The Long Duel
    • Looking at Lincoln - Spielberg's "Lincoln" & its predecessors and influences >
      • Spielberg's Lincoln
      • Abraham Lincoln: D.W. Griffith's version
      • Young Mr. Lincoln (1939)
      • Abe Lincoln in Illinois
    • Mandingo (1975) Dir: Richard Fleischer
    • The Man Who Would Be King
    • Marie Antoinette (2006)
    • Marie-Antoinette / Shadow of the Guillotine
    • Farewell, My Queen
    • Marie Antoinette (1938) >
      • Marie Antoinette (1938) Pt.2
    • Mayerling
    • Midnight in Paris >
      • Midnight in Paris:2 >
        • Midnight in Paris:3
    • The Monuments Men (2014) Dir: George Clooney
    • North West Frontier / Flame Over India
    • La Nuit de Varennes - a post-modern take on a key episode in the French Revolution
    • Le Pere Tranquille (The Quiet Father) 1946
    • Peterloo: MIke Leigh's New Movie >
      • Peterloo2
    • Pompeii in the movies >
      • Pompeii (2014) Paul W.S. Anderson director
    • Rebel Without a Cause
    • Ridicule
    • Scott Fitzgerald Goes to Hollywood
    • Sergeant Rutledge
    • Silence of the Sea
    • Swing Kids (1993)
    • The Train
    • Train to Pakistan
    • Stranglers of Bombay
    • Tonka
    • Tulip Fever
    • Viceroy's House
    • The Vikings
    • Vietnam Westerns: western movies and the Vietnam war
    • Wee Willie Winkie
    • The Wind and the Lion
    • Woman in Gold >
      • Woman in Gold Pt.2: the Vienna Scene in early 20th Century Vienna
    • Un village française: French TV series
    • Waterloo: the movie about Napoleon's final battle
    • Zabriskie Point
  • Places
    • Settings: the North West Frontier
    • Movies Set in the North-West Frontier >
      • Thuggees
    • Movies Set in Paris and Versailles
  • Events
    • Events That Inspired Movies 2
    • French Resistance and Collaboration in World War II: Selected Movies
  • People
    • People Part 2
  • Music
    • Rock Around the Clock
    • Don't Knock the Rock
    • The Girl Can't Help It >
      • Pt2:The Girl Can't Help It
  • Free State of Jones
  • Great Wall (2017)
  • Rogue One & World War 2
  • Hollywood and anti-Americanism in a small country: Amercan movies & their critics in New Zealand 1916 - 1956
    • New Zealanders' Love of Movies 1900s-1956
    • Campaign against Hollywood movies in New Zealand
    • Campaign against HollywoodPt 2
  • Hollywood versus Pinewood Pt2
  • New Zealanders and Movies: the Enigmatic Gordon Mirams: film critic, film censor and public intellectual
  • Aryan Papers: Stanley Kubrick's Proposed Movie

Lives of a Bengal Lancer (1935) - Dir: Henry Hathaway

Picture
Picture
Picture

Film critic Adolf Hitler on why Lives of a Bengal Lancer was one of his  favourite films

In 1937 Hitler told the British Foreign Secretary Lord Halifax that Lives of a Bengal Lancer  was one of his favorite films. According to the Fuhrer, It showed a "handful of Britons holding a continent in thrall. That was how a superior race must behave and the film was compulsory viewing for the S.S." 
Source: Ivone Kirkpatrick, The Inner Circle [London:Macmillan, 1959, p.97. Kirkpatrick was a senior Foreign Office official  and diplomat who specialised in German affairs. He was sent by Churchill to interview Rudolf Hess after the later landed in Scotland in 1941.He rose to the top of the Foreign Office ranks in the 1950s.

About the movie

Picture
Henry Hathaway's 1935 movie Lives of a Bengal Lancer is largely forgotten today. Most people would associate  'Bengal Lancer'  with an Indian restaurant or an Indian cricket team. Yet in its time the movie was the equivalent of aSpiderman movie today. It remains famous for making a longtime box office star of Gary Cooper. And it was one of the early 'buddy movie' successes, still popular today, in which a group of friends boldly fight incredible odds in the cause of country and glory. Harrison Ford's Indianna Jones' derring-do seems modelled on Cooper's character. It was also a breakthrough movie for its director, Henry Hathaway, who went on to make many first-rate actioners and westerns, several with John Wayne (e.g. True Grit, Sons of Katie Elder).
One feature of the film that would be not be appreciated by most modern film-goers is its seriousness. The tongue-in-cheek irony of the Indianna Jones films (already beginning to be a bit dated itself) is entirely absent. Although made in Hollywood with a Hollywood director and crew, it retains its source's stereotyped stiff-British-upper-lip ethos. Another negative feature is the movie's condescending andf paternalistic racial attitudes: British heroism and camaraderie is required to foil villainous natives and protect the childlike and naive good Indians. As that observant enthusiast of the film, Herr Hitler noted, Bengal Lancers maintains that a handful of Europeans can rule an entire continent of 'lesser' races.

The movie is set in some vague part of the Northwest Frontier involving the '41st Bengal Lancers'. Gary Cooper is a headstrong officer who initially dislikes and then befriends two new subalterns, one of whom just happens to be  the son of the regiment's C.O. There are bonding sessions, ungrateful rebellious Muslim tribes, a kidnapping, snake-charming, father-son conflict, a sultry woman of mystery, a torture scene (this is the one where the villain actually sneers 'We have ways of making men talk') and a heroic rescue scene.
One feature of Bengal Lancers is significant. This  movie is essentially a cavalry eastern, like KIng of the Khyber Rifles and North West Frontier / Flame Over India. It contains a vital element that was seized upon by the great John Ford and honed to perfection in his films about the U.S. Cavalry e.g. Fort Apache.This is the theme of the bonds and obligations of community (e.g. the regiment) and the tensions and conflicts that result, as well as the sustaining sense of cohesion and protection that ensue. It is this sense of communal commitment portrayed in Lancers that Ford employs so well in Fort Apache (below) and hisgreat films about regimental life in the Cavalry.

Picture
Picture

About the book

Picture
The movie was based on the memoirs of Francis Yeats-Brown (1886-1944). Published in 1930, the book covered the author's time in the Bengal Lancers in the decade before World War I. Yeats-Brown had a privileged upbringing (Harrow and Sandhurst), and joined the British army in India. He soon became part of the Bengal Lancers, serving in the turbulent North West Frontier. During World War I Yeats-Brown served in the Royal Flying Corps in France and Iraq, gaining a DFC for bravery. He was a prisoner of war for two years after beiong captured by the Turks. After the war he reurned to the Indian army for four years. He then became a journalist. The publication of his book about military cantonment life in the Lancers, replete with tales of polo, pig-sticking, officers' pranks, lavish dances, complicated military etiquette and even his liason with an Indian dancing-girl was a success with critics and the public. The movie credits list the memoir as a 'novel', which may well bea more  accurate description.
During the 1930s Yeats-Brown became associated with fascism, praising Franco and Hitler. During World War II he resumed his earlier career as an officer in India. 

Picture
Yeats-Brown's book includes many stories of life as a Lancer at Bareilly Cantonment, in north-west India's frontier region. This cantonment is at Barrackpore.

Scenes from the movie

Picture
The romantic element is hardly a crucial element in 'Lancers'.
Picture
Treacherous native villain scheming against the brave British rukers: racial stereotyping is a feature of movies of this era.
Picture
The famous 'We have ways of making a man talk' scene.
Picture
The action scenes are still well worth watching today.

Who were the Bengal Lancers?

Picture
Bengal Lancers in Afghanistan, 1879.
Picture
13th Bengal Lancers 1870.
Picture
Scouts of the 10th Bengal Lancers
The Bengal Lancers that Yeats-Brown's best-seller describes were the regiment  known as the 8th Bengal Lancers, stationed at Bareilly cantonment, in northern India, 100kms from the Himalayan foothills. They were part of Britain's largely locally recruited forces in India (as distinct from units of the British Army stationed in the sub-continent). They provide a perfect example of how so few Britons were able to rule such an enormous and heavily populated land: a key part of the imperial military presence  consisted of local forces acting under British control in the form of the officer corps. 
Just before Yeats-Brown took up his post these 'native' units, divided into the Bengal Army, the Bombay Army and the Madras Army,had been combined into a single unit, called the Indian Army. All these regiments had British officers. At that time there were nineteen regiments of Bengal Lancers stationed in various parts of northern India. The regiment depicted in the movie is entirely fictional. 
The Bengal Lancers originally were a cavalry unit, and traced its parentage back to the private army of the East India Company, before becoming part of the Bengal Army after the Mutiny /Uprising. The fought in Afghanistan in 1879. In 1899 they were fitted with lances and became the 8th Belgian Lancers. Fittingly, the unit is now the 3rd Cavalry  (armoured) in today's Indian Army. Several of the Bengal Lancer units fought overseas, including Egypt and Sudan (1882-5),  the Boer War in South Africa and on the western front in World War I, including the Somme and Cambrai. Other units served in Mesopotamia (Iraq).
See Graham Watson, Indian Army, 1902, http://orbat.com/site/history/historical/uk/indianarmy1902.html; http://battledescription.com/bengal-lancer/ ; http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/8th_Lancers)
Picture
An idealised, inaccuratel portrait of Bengal Lancers charging German cavalry at the battle of Ypres, October 1914.
Picture
This may be a more realistic portrayal of the Bengal Lancers charging German trecnches at the battle. One thing is certain: at Ypres the Indians had to fight on foot. Source: Illustrated War News, 18 Nov.1914.
The painting above left shows Bengal Lancers triumphantly charging into battle against German cavalry at Ypres, 1914. The illustration above right shows them charging a German trench on foot. Eyewitness accounts prove the painting to be a fabrication. In fact, the  military situation on the western front  was so dire and manpower so depleted that the British flung the Lancers into action almost as soon as the unit arrived in France. This meant that the Lancers fought at Ypres as 'Dismounted Infantry', not as cavalry. They also fought in their light tropical outfit (plus a flannel shirt and jersey) and  light boots; there was no time to equip them properly. It is unknown whether they were issued rifles rather than lances. 
"The British Expeditionary Force holding the line of shallow, badly-made trenches from Ypres to La Bassee was subjected to a series of massive German attacks designed to clear Belgium and capture Calais. At a critical stage when the Germans seemed on the point of making a breakthrough the Indian Corps were brought up as reinforcements. In half waterlogged trenches, under constant attacks by German Infantry, who outnumbered them by at least seven to one, the Indian Corps fought with the utmost gallantry alongside the seasoned veterans of the British Expeditionary Force. At the end of four weeks of the heaviest fighting experienced in the war the line held. Ypres remained unconquered. In the words of Lord Harding, Viceroy of India: "It is to the abiding glory of the Indian Corps that it reached France in the first great crisis of the war. The only trained reinforcements immediately available in any part of the empire arrived in time to stem the German thrust towards Ypres and the Channel ports during the autumn of 1914. They consecrated with their blood the unity of India with the empire; and few indeed are the survivors of that gallant force." 
Source: Wakefield, Col. J., and Lt. Col. J.M. Weippert, eds., 1986, Indian Cavalry Officer 1914-15 – Captain Roly Grimshaw:Tunbridge Wells, Kent, England, D.J. Costello,

Henry Hathaway - neglected and underrated director

Picture
Henry Hathaway, 1898 - 1985.
Henry Hathaway directed more than sixty films, many of them with major stars such as John Wayne and James Stewart, but his work has been ignored by critics or favoured with polite evaluations such as 'competent' and 'professional'.  There are several reasons for this neglect. Most of his films were apparently straight-forward actioners or westerns, genres frequently despised by some critics. His work also seems to lacks underlying themes and obsessions for critics to latch onto. He was not a notable stylist, although most of his films have a satisfying narrative fluency and exemplary pacing. Hathaway didn't write his own scripts or produce  his own films. Finally, he worked contentedly within the Hollywood studio system for decades, first with Paramount then with Fox, directing movies on assignment for his producer bosses, rather like his contemporary, Henry King, director of King of the Khyber Rifles. Hathaway was  not a Nicholas Ray chafing under the confines of studio regimes, although he occasionally angered them with his stubborn insistence on getting the lighting style he wanted from his cameraman. Directors like KIng and Hathaway who were at ease with the big studio restrictions never feature highly in critics' assessments. Yet Hathaway, like more favoured directors like William Wyler, was a stickler for detail, insisted on repeated takes of scenes until he was satisfied, and was highly knowledgeable about the use artists made of shade, light and perspective.

Picture
Picture
Picture
Picture
Hathaway's skills are best revealed in two genres that he specialised in making. The most important of these were the thrillers of the 1940s and early 1950s, with their semi-documentary, shot-on-location style and film noir characters and subjects. These include 13 Rue Madeleine , Kiss of Death,  Call Northside 777 and Niagara. Early in his career Hathaway made Westerns (Heritage of the Desert and Trail of the Lonesome Pine) and he returned to that genre in the sixties, making a series of interesting, idiosyncratic movies, frequently with the theme of family commitment , often starring John Wayne. The best known of these are True Grit and The Sons of Katie Elder.  Other westerns include  Nevada Smith with Steve McQueen, and Five Card Stud. 

More Movies About the the British Raj and India in Cliomuse.com

Picture
Picture
Picture
Picture
Picture