Cliomuse.com
Where history and movies meet
Cliomuse.com
  • Featured Movies
    • 12 Years a Slave (2013)
    • 1941 (Spielberg) >
      • 1941: Part 2
    • Affair of the Necklace
    • Alice's Restaurant: best of the American counterculture movies?
    • Army of Crime
    • Army of Shadows
    • The Artist >
      • 'The Artist':2
    • Anthropoid: the Assassination of Reinhard Heydrich, 1942: Four Very Different Movies >
      • Hangmen Also Die: Hollywood meets emigres from Nazi Germany
    • Autobiography of Miss Jane Pittman
    • Battle of the Rails ( La bataille du rail)
    • Belle (2014)
    • Bhowani Junction
    • Blackboard Jungle >
      • Blackboard Jungle Pt.2
    • Carry On Up the Khyber
    • Charlie Wilson's War
    • The City Across the River
    • The Counterculture : best movies about the American counterculture era
    • Custer - two contrasting movie portrayals: "They Died With Their Boots On" and "Little Big Man" >
      • They Died With Their Boots On
      • Stalin and the Movies >
        • Stalin, Disney, Eisenstein, & Ivan the Terrible
      • Death of Stalin
      • Little Big Man (1970)
    • Dark Knight Rises >
      • Dark Knight Rises Pt.2
    • The Deceivers
    • Diplomacy / Diplomatie (2014) movie
    • Dunkirk: Christopher Nolan's epic movie
    • El Cid
    • The Enigma Machine : four movies about the Enigma machine
    • Generation War >
      • Generation War: Jazz and the Swing Kids
      • Generation War: German women and the war
    • The Great Gatsby On the Big Screen
    • Gunga Din
    • A Hard Day's Night: Influences on the Movie
    • Hemingway & Gellhorn >
      • Martha Gellhorn >
        • Women war correspondents
    • Hyde Park on Hudson
    • The Imitation Game (2014) >
      • The Imitation Game Part 2: the truth about Turing and the Bletchley 'Bombe'. >
        • The Imitation Game: Turing, Bletchley and the Colossus >
          • Imitation Game: Turing, Bletchley Park and the Soviet spy
    • The Inner Circle (1991)
    • Is Paris Burning? >
      • Is Paris Burning? General von Choltitz
    • KIng of the Khyber Rifles
    • Kim
    • Léon Morin, Priest
    • Les Miserables (2012) >
      • Les Miserables in Movies: Fantine the grisette >
        • Les Miserables 3: guide to some historical references
    • "Les Misérables": Claude Lelouch updates a classic
    • Lives of a Bengal Lancer (1935)
    • The Long Duel
    • Looking at Lincoln - Spielberg's "Lincoln" & its predecessors and influences >
      • Spielberg's Lincoln
      • Abraham Lincoln: D.W. Griffith's version
      • Young Mr. Lincoln (1939)
      • Abe Lincoln in Illinois
    • Mandingo (1975) Dir: Richard Fleischer
    • The Man Who Would Be King
    • Marie Antoinette (2006)
    • Marie-Antoinette / Shadow of the Guillotine
    • Farewell, My Queen
    • Marie Antoinette (1938) >
      • Marie Antoinette (1938) Pt.2
    • Mayerling
    • Midnight in Paris >
      • Midnight in Paris:2 >
        • Midnight in Paris:3
    • The Monuments Men (2014) Dir: George Clooney
    • North West Frontier / Flame Over India
    • La Nuit de Varennes - a post-modern take on a key episode in the French Revolution
    • Le Pere Tranquille (The Quiet Father) 1946
    • Peterloo: MIke Leigh's New Movie >
      • Peterloo2
    • Pompeii in the movies >
      • Pompeii (2014) Paul W.S. Anderson director
    • Rebel Without a Cause
    • Ridicule
    • Scott Fitzgerald Goes to Hollywood
    • Sergeant Rutledge
    • Silence of the Sea
    • Swing Kids (1993)
    • The Train
    • Train to Pakistan
    • Stranglers of Bombay
    • Tonka
    • Tulip Fever
    • Viceroy's House
    • The Vikings
    • Vietnam Westerns: western movies and the Vietnam war
    • Wee Willie Winkie
    • The Wind and the Lion
    • Woman in Gold >
      • Woman in Gold Pt.2: the Vienna Scene in early 20th Century Vienna
    • Un village française: French TV series
    • Waterloo: the movie about Napoleon's final battle
    • Zabriskie Point
  • Places
    • Settings: the North West Frontier
    • Movies Set in the North-West Frontier >
      • Thuggees
    • Movies Set in Paris and Versailles
  • Events
    • Events That Inspired Movies 2
    • French Resistance and Collaboration in World War II: Selected Movies
  • People
    • People Part 2
  • Music
    • Rock Around the Clock
    • Don't Knock the Rock
    • The Girl Can't Help It >
      • Pt2:The Girl Can't Help It
  • Free State of Jones
  • Great Wall (2017)
  • Rogue One & World War 2
  • Hollywood and anti-Americanism in a small country: Amercan movies & their critics in New Zealand 1916 - 1956
    • New Zealanders' Love of Movies 1900s-1956
    • Campaign against Hollywood movies in New Zealand
    • Campaign against HollywoodPt 2
  • Hollywood versus Pinewood Pt2
  • New Zealanders and Movies: the Enigmatic Gordon Mirams: film critic, film censor and public intellectual

Marie Antoinette (1938)
Why is the 1938 version superior to the 2006 version?

The older biopic gives a richer, more detailed and more accurate portrayal of court life.

Picture
Picture
Picture
The Norma Shearer movie makes it clear that the royal court under Louis XVI and Marie Antoinette was the focus of political and social contests whose outcomes had significant and sometimes dangerous consequences. The outcomes of courtly scandals, factions and extravagances had resonances that extended beyond Versailles into Paris and the nation. The film makes it clear that the King and Queen eventually realise this, but their actions are to repair the damage occur too late. The Coppola version, by contrast, persists in treating the court as a mere playground for the privileged aristocracy. Her film shows no awareness of the court's vital function as a political battleground and pays little attention to the political actions of the royal couple. And strangely, the black and white photography as of van Dyke's movie gives the court a more regal and imposing presence than do the pastels of Coppola's version. Whereas her film's courtiers seem to be young, ineffectual but harmless, van Dyke's courtiers are older, scheming, threatening and malevolent. 
Picture
Let them eat cake and wear designer shoes.... Pink pastels dominate the settings, a motif which soon becomes bland and repetitive.
Picture
The young royal couple. Unfortunately, neither appear to age or alter much during Coppola's film, unlike the 1938 version.
Picture
In the 2006 movie, Marie Antoinette merges into the pastel backgrounds, unlike the distinctive and assertive royal presence in the black and white version of 1938.

The earlier movie  provides a more thorough and perceptive portrayal of the  Queen and her husband.
The malevolent and dangerous social and political atmosphere of the court is found only in the 1938 film.
It also encompasses a much wider emotional and political range range than the 2006 movie.
Norma Shearer, as Marie Antoinette, is given more opportunities to shine as an actress than Kirsten Dunst.
The MGM movie's depiction of the royal family's imprisonment  makes an effective contrast to the luxury of Versailles.

Picture
Scene from 1938 movie showing Marie Antoinette with her two children in prison.
Picture
The poignancy of Marie Antoinette's last days, conveyed effectively by Shearer's performance, gives the 1938 movie a moral seriousness lacking in the 2006 version.
Picture
Order of the Committee of Public Safety separating the young Dauphin from his mother after the execution of Louis XVI..
Picture
The 1938 film presents the court as a world of dangerous intrigue and faction, an aspect largely ignored in the politically naive production seven decades later.
Picture
The final third of the 1938 movie focused on the plight of Marie, Louis and their children as prisoners of the revolution, giving the film a tension lacking in Coppola's version, which completely ignored post-revolution events.
Picture
Marie's imprisonment and trial, and her protection of her husband and children, give her character in the 1938 film a dignity and gravitas that are not found in the more recent version.

La Conciergerie: the last home of the royal family

Picture
La Conciergerie is located in central Paris on the Seine. Built 1302-1313, it is well worth a visit. Essential for anyone interested in the French Revolution and Marie Antoinette.
Picture
Marie Antoinette's cell in La Conciergerie.
Picture
Another cell in the prison. Most cells had no bed, straw floors, with many prisoners crammed inside. Disease probably killed more than the guillotine.
Picture
Courtyard for women prisoners at La Conciergerie. Marie Antoinette walked here.
Picture
Location of La Conciergerie in Paris. Note nearest Metro -easy access.